Charles & Colvard, Ltd.: A Deep Dive into Their 10-K Filing and Its Investment Potential

Charles & Colvard, Ltd. is a name that has historically been synonymous with innovation in the jewelry industry, most notably in the realm of lab-grown moissanite and, more recently, lab-grown diamonds. The company has proudly touted its status as the original source of created moissanite and has built a brand around its flagship product, Forever One™, along with its newer brand Caydia® for premium lab-grown diamonds. However, as we walk through the extensive 10-K filing for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2024, a more nuanced picture emerges—one marked both by the company’s legacy of innovation and by a series of significant financial and operational challenges.

Warren.AI 💰 3 / 10

Business Overview

Charles & Colvard operates in two main segments: Online Channels and Traditional Sales. The Online Channels segment encompasses the company’s proprietary e-commerce websites (such as charlesandcolvard.com, moissaniteoutlet.com, and madenetwork.com), third-party online marketplaces, and drop-ship arrangements. The Traditional segment, on the other hand, covers sales through distributors, retail partners, and the company's own brick-and-mortar outlet—the Charles & Colvard Signature Showroom.

The firm’s mission has always been to offer a conflict‐free and ethically sourced fine jewelry experience. Their emphasis on "Made, not Mined™" continues to shape branding and marketing messages. Recently, the company expanded its product portfolio into lab-grown diamonds under the Caydia® brand, aiming to capture a broader share of the ethically sourced jewelry market.

Financial Performance: A Mixed Bag

One of the most striking aspects of the 10-K filing is the financial performance. For the fiscal year ended June 30, 2024, the company reported net sales of approximately $21.96 million—a significant decline of 27% compared to $29.95 million in fiscal 2023. This decline in revenue is a red flag for investors, deeply rooted in diminished consumer demand in an economy that is feeling the pressure from inflation, recessionary fears, and intensified competition in the fine jewelry sector.

Net Loss and Expense Breakdown

The consolidated statement of operations tells us that the company experienced a net loss of approximately $14.36 million in fiscal 2024. While this loss is lower than the nearly $19.58 million net loss recorded in the prior year, it remains a substantial negative figure. The loss stems from several factors:

• Higher Costs and Expenses: The cost of goods sold, which includes a combination of direct production costs and indirect expenses (such as manufacturing overhead and inventory adjustments), represents a significant part of the expense base. The drop in net sales was partly offset by lower product-related costs due to lower production volumes, but the overall expense structure still pressured margins.
• Sales and Marketing Costs: Despite a modest decrease in sales and marketing expenses, these costs remain high relative to the declining revenue base. The competitive landscape has forced the company to invest heavily in digital marketing and brand awareness, an area where results typically take time to materialize.
• General and Administrative Expenses: While these expenses saw a slight increase, the overall burden of administrative costs combined with legal settlements further strained the bottom line.

Legal and Operational Risks

Another significant headwind comes from the legal front. The company was embroiled in an arbitration with Wolfspeed, its primary supplier of silicon carbide (SiC) crystals. On July 28, 2023, Wolfspeed initiated a confidential arbitration alleging a breach of contract and claiming damages. By February 10, 2025, a settlement agreement was reached, with the company agreeing to pay a total of $4.77 million. Although a portion of this payment has been made, it remains a liability until fully settled.

Liquidity Concerns and the Going Concern Warning

The 10-K filing contains a stark message regarding the company’s liquidity. The management discussion indicates that cash flows from operations were notably negative—approximately $7.37 million used in 2024, compared to $3.88 million in fiscal 2023. Working capital has also decreased significantly. More worryingly, the company explicitly states that its current cash and equivalent resources may not be sufficient to meet its working capital and capital expenditure needs for the next 12 months.

This situation has led to a "going concern" warning in the financial statements. In simple terms, the company acknowledges that it faces substantial doubt about its ability to continue operating over the next year unless it can secure additional financing, effectively cut expenses, or improve operational efficiency.

Operational Challenges and Strategic Initiatives

Cybersecurity Incident

In the modern digital age, cybersecurity is a critical risk area, and Charles & Colvard is no exception. The company disclosed a cybersecurity incident that occurred around June 28, 2023. The incident, which involved a ransomware attack that temporarily disrupted IT operations, was contained quickly with no evidence of sensitive customer data being compromised. However, the associated costs—approximately $300,000 in 2024—added to the financial strain, even though a significant portion was covered by insurance.

Reverse Stock Split

The filing also reveals that the company executed a 1-for-10 reverse stock split on May 17, 2024. Reverse splits are typically used by companies to boost their share price—often in response to regulatory pressures or to avoid delisting from exchanges (as was the case here, with Nasdaq previously notifying them about their share price dropping below $1.00). While reverse splits do not change the underlying value of a shareholder’s stake, they are a signal that market conditions have pressured the stock, affecting investor sentiment.

Digital Transformation and Brand Awareness Efforts

On a more positive note, management is clearly investing in digital transformation. The launch of a NextGen website platform has reportedly improved site load times, SEO performance, and overall user experience. Enhanced digital marketing strategies and strategic partnerships—including celebrity endorsements and collaborations with influencers—are part of an effort to boost brand awareness and capture new market segments.

These strategic initiatives are designed to address a changing market by appealing to a broader and younger consumer base who are drawn to ethically sourced and technologically advanced jewelry options. However, while these efforts might promise long-term benefits, the near-term financial pressures and structural challenges remain daunting.

Market and Competitive Landscape

The fine jewelry industry is highly competitive and is currently being reshaped by shifting consumer preferences. The growing acceptance of lab-grown diamonds and alternative gemstones has put traditional mined diamond businesses under pressure. Charles & Colvard competes not only with other moissanite producers but also with companies offering lab-grown diamonds, as well as traditional diamond retailers. The intense competition means that pricing pressures are high, and any reduction in consumer discretionary spending (which is very likely in times of economic uncertainty) can quickly impact sales volumes.

Moreover, the company is reliant on a limited number of distributors and retail partners, especially in its Traditional segment. This concentration of customers increases exposure to credit risk—if one of these customers experiences financial distress, it could have a material adverse impact on the company’s revenues.

Investment Considerations and Risks

Investors considering a position in Charles & Colvard should pay close attention to several key factors:

1. Financial Health: The company is currently reporting substantial net losses, and while there was a slight improvement in losses from the previous year, the downward pressure on revenue and margins is significant. The going concern warning is a major red flag.
2. Liquidity and Operating Cash Flow: The negative cash flows from operations, coupled with diminishing working capital, raise concerns about the company’s ability to fund its day-to-day activities without accessing additional financing, which may come at unfavorable terms.
3. Legal and Supplier Risks: The arbitration with Wolfspeed highlights the risks associated with dependence on a single supplier. Even though a settlement has been reached, it underscores potential vulnerabilities in the supply chain.
4. Market and Economic Headwinds: The broader economic challenges—rising inflation, consumer tightening in discretionary spending, and a competitive market with shifting consumer preferences—pose significant risks that could further depress sales.
5. Strategic Initiatives vs. Near-Term Financial Needs: While the company is investing in digital transformation, enhanced marketing efforts, and new product lines, the benefits from these initiatives are typically seen over the long term. In the near term, the financial challenges remain acute.

Concluding Thoughts

Charles & Colvard has built a respected brand over a long history in the jewelry industry. Its leadership in lab-grown moissanite remains a unique value proposition, and its recent foray into lab-grown diamonds reflects an adaptive strategy to capture emerging market trends. However, the 10-K filing for Fiscal 2024 paints a picture of a company under significant financial and operational distress—marked by substantial net losses, a 27% decline in sales, liquidity challenges, and a strong caution regarding its ability to continue as a going concern. The company’s reverse stock split and legal settlement with Wolfspeed further emphasize the pressures it faces.

For potential investors, Charles & Colvard represents a high-risk proposition. The brand’s innovative history and niche market position are positive, but the immediate financial risks and ongoing operational issues create a challenging environment for near-term returns. Prospective investors should carefully weigh the long-term growth potential in an increasingly competitive and uncertain market against the current financial instability and liquidity risks.

In our analysis, we have assigned an investment score of 3 out of 10 to the company. This score reflects the high risk, significant ongoing losses, and liquidity concerns described in the 10-K filing. While there could be long-term potential if the company reverses its current trends and strengthens its financials, the near-term challenges present considerable hazards for investors.

Ultimately, any investment in Charles & Colvard should be approached with caution, and investors should consider whether they are comfortable with the high-risk profile and the possibility of further capital requirements or dilution as the company seeks to navigate its current challenges. Continued monitoring of sales trends, operational improvements, and the company’s ability to access additional financing will be critical for assessing whether Charles & Colvard can transition from its current precarious position to a more stable, growth-oriented phase in the future.